Address
5F, 526 Nonhyeon-ro,
Gangnam-gu, Seoul, Korea
Address
5F, 526 Nonhyeon-ro,
Gangnam-gu, Seoul, Korea
C&K Law Offices advised a Korean company operating a Web3 platform based on decentralised wallets and reviewed the legal issues concerning the handling of tokens left in wallets when users leave the service. The matter shows that even with non-custodial wallets the operator cannot access, disputes can arise if users are not told in advance what happens to their assets after they leave.
Under the client’s service, users create personal wallets through Web3Auth and keep tokens earned on the platform in those non-custodial wallets. The service was designed so that the operator could not access the wallets technically or legally, but users repeatedly asked what would happen to their tokens after leaving.
The central question was what responsibility and duty of disclosure the operator has regarding departing users’ tokens when it cannot access the wallets.
After reviewing the service structure and screen design, C&K Law Offices set standards for the operator’s scope of responsibility and duty of disclosure. First, we had the company give notice that wallets and tokens remain intact after a user leaves and that the company has no authority to access the wallets. Next, we had it state in the terms that the company has no authority to return or extinguish tokens.
We also recommended improving the screen flow so that, before leaving, users back up their wallets and check their Web3Auth account details. Notices alone are easily missed, so having users confirm these points directly during the leaving process is what makes the measure effective.
The client put in place a disclosure system able to deal with recurring user enquiries and clarified the company’s scope of responsibility, reducing the potential for disputes over infringement of property rights or breach of the Act on the Regulation of Standardised Contracts.
Non-custodial wallets have the advantage that the operator does not hold assets, but users often do not fully understand this. Giving sufficient notice at moments when users may lose access to their assets, such as leaving the service or the service closing, can reduce disputes. It is therefore advisable to design the actual screens to take users through backup and confirmation steps, in addition to the wording of the terms.
With a non-custodial wallet, the tokens remain in the wallet. If you lose the information needed to access the wallet, however, you will not be able to use them either.
Responsibility for the assets themselves may be limited, but failing to explain the structure and risks adequately may give rise to a breach of the duty of disclosure.
More on our work is available on our Crypto Regulation & Advisory page. For enquiries, contact us at contact@chakwon.com.