HOME / Updates / Selected Matters

Virtual Asset Referral Marketing Compliance Advisory

Selected Matters

Practice areaCrypto Legal Advisory
Case Summary

C&K Law Offices advised a company running a marketing business using an overseas virtual asset exchange’s referral programme and reviewed whether the marketing language it planned to use when introducing a points scheme could be problematic in terms of regulation or misleading users. The matter shows that putting an undecided token plan into promotional language risks users taking it as a confirmed investment opportunity.

01Overview

On launching a new points system, the client intended to use short-term marketing language such as “possible future conversion to tokens” and “token launch plans”. No actual plan to issue tokens had been settled, however.

02Issues

Two questions were reviewed in this matter.

  1. 1

    Whether token-related language could be perceived by users as an inducement to invest or be assessed as exaggerated advertising.

  2. 2

    Whether, depending on how Korean-language marketing channels were operated, the referral business could be interpreted as targeting Korea or as unreported virtual asset business.

03Our Work

Focusing on the actual operation and degree of marketing involvement rather than the form of the referral business, C&K Law Offices reviewed whether the language could be assessed under the virtual asset service provider rules of the Act on Reporting and Using Specified Financial Transaction Information, as unreported business, or as misleading or exaggerated advertising.

In particular, we analysed the risk that token conversion language used on its own would be taken by users as a confirmed plan, and that the business could be interpreted as targeting Korea depending on who ran the Korean-language channels and how. A single phrase can lead to a regulatory assessment of the whole business.

04Outcome

C&K Law Offices explained that any token conversion language must be accompanied by a clear statement that the plan is “under review” and “not confirmed”, and that the risk of Korean regulation could increase unless the operator and scope of involvement of the marketing channels were actually managed. We also identified issues that could arise as the business expanded and provided practical guidelines.

05Why This Case Matters

Promoting points as convertible into tokens later is effective for attracting users. Putting this forward while the plan is unsettled, however, can look like a promise of expected returns and lead to disputes if the plan falls through. It is therefore advisable to state clearly that unconfirmed plans are unconfirmed and to check that the way channels are run does not look like doing business in Korea.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q. May I promote points as convertible into tokens?

If the plan is not confirmed, that must be stated clearly. Promoting it as if confirmed may be problematic as misleading advertising or an inducement to invest.

Q. Does running a Korean-language channel count as doing business in Korea?

Running a channel alone does not decide it, but it can be a sign of actively doing business with Korean users. The operator and the content are considered together.

More on our work is available on our Crypto Regulation & Advisory page. For enquiries, contact us at contact@chakwon.com.

All updates

Live ChatContact Us