HOME / Updates / Selected Matters

Advisory and Representation in Damages Claims Arising from Mis-selling of Private Equity Funds

Selected Matters

Lawyer
Shinyoung ChoiPartner
Case Summary

C&K Law Offices provided advice and litigation representation for an investor who suffered losses from the mis-selling of a private equity fund. The matter shows that even where procedures such as recordings and signatures were followed in the sales process, whether the risks were actually explained sufficiently can be examined separately.

01Background

The client invested in a high-risk private equity fund product recommended by a financial investment company and suffered losses. At issue was whether, in the sales process, the company had recommended a product suited to the client’s investment profile, financial situation and investment experience, and whether it had properly explained the product’s risks.

02Issues

There were three questions to examine in this case.

  1. 1

    Whether there were explanations in the sales process leading the client to expect principal protection or stable returns.

  2. 2

    Whether the product structure and the risks of the underlying assets were specifically disclosed.

  3. 3

    Whether the recording and written confirmation procedures were merely formal.

03Our Work

Based on the suitability principle, the duty to explain and the prohibition on improper solicitation under the Financial Investment Services and Capital Markets Act and the related case law, C&K Law Offices analysed the unlawfulness of the sales conduct. Reviewing together the product description, investment solicitation rules, internal control standards, recordings and consultation records, we built our arguments by distinguishing formal compliance with procedures from substantive performance of the duty to explain. Financial investment companies usually argue that they explained on the basis of signatures and recordings, so the key was to show whether the content was actually at a level enabling the investor to understand the risks.

We also organised the loss based on the amount invested, amounts recovered, any interim distributions and the date the loss crystallised, and specified causation and the apportionment of liability. Comparing Financial Supervisory Service dispute mediation cases and similar judgments, we derived a reasonable scope of liability.

04Why This Case Matters

In mis-selling disputes, investors often think they cannot contest the matter because they signed the documents. The courts, however, look not only at whether documents exist but also at whether the explanation was sufficient in light of the investor’s profile and experience. If losses have occurred, it is therefore advisable first to secure the explanatory materials, recordings and consultation records from the time of subscription, and then consider whether dispute mediation or litigation is the right route.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q. If I signed the subscription documents, can I not obtain damages?

You may. Even with a signature, liability for damages may be found if the explanation was substantively inadequate or an unsuitable product was recommended.

Q. Are damages awarded for the full investment loss?

In most cases the investor’s own fault is also taken into account in setting the apportionment of liability, which varies with investment experience and the extent of the explanation received.

Q. Is there a procedure available before litigation?

An application for dispute mediation can be made to the Financial Supervisory Service. Many investors decide whether to sue after seeing the outcome of mediation.

For enquiries, contact us at contact@chakwon.com.

All updates

Live ChatContact Us