HOME / Updates / Selected Matters

Liability & Response: Identity Theft Fraud

Selected Matters

Lawyer
Shinyoung ChoiPartner
Case Summary

C&K Law Offices advised a victim whose identity had been used without authorisation to carry out financial transactions and conclude contracts. The matter shows that, in identity theft cases, a civil response denying the debt and a criminal response against the person who used the identity must be designed together.

01Background

The client discovered that financial transactions and contracts had been concluded in the client’s name without the client’s knowledge. It was necessary to establish whether the client had to bear those debts and what liability could be pursued against the person who misused the identity.

02Issues

There were three questions to examine in this matter.

  1. 1

    Whether a contract concluded without the person’s own intention is effective.

  2. 2

    What criminal liability arises from the misuse of the identity.

  3. 3

    Whether the debts are attributable to the victim. In particular, how electronic signatures were made and accounts accessed, whether identity verification procedures were adequate, and whether the financial institution or counterparty was at fault were important factors in determining liability.

03Our Work

Focusing on the requirements for formation of a contract and defects in the declaration of intention, C&K Law Offices reviewed whether the debts could be regarded as non-existent. A contract requires the intention of the parties, so the starting point was to show that the client had not been involved in the contract.

We also analysed whether criminal liability such as fraud, forgery of private documents and breach of the Electronic Financial Transactions Act could apply to the misuse of identity. We then organised civil remedies such as payment suspension, declaratory actions that no debt exists and damages claims in the right order, and set out a strategy for settling the legal relationships and establishing who is liable.

04Why This Case Matters

As non-face-to-face financial transactions increase, so do losses from contracts concluded by misusing identity documents or authentication means. If the victim delays responding, however, arrears records and collection efforts can follow, increasing the harm. On learning of identity theft, it is therefore advisable first to notify the financial institution and request measures such as payment suspension, secure materials on how the contracts were concluded and then consider civil and criminal proceedings together.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q. Should I repay a loan in my name in the meantime?

If you did not enter into the contract, you can dispute that the debt exists. The outcome may vary, however, with the financial institution’s identity verification procedures and the extent of the victim’s own carelessness, so it is important to document how it happened.

Q. Can a criminal complaint and a civil action be pursued together?

Yes. The results of the investigation can also serve as evidence of how the contract was concluded in the civil action.

For enquiries, contact us at contact@chakwon.com.

All updates

Live ChatContact Us