HOME / Updates / Selected Matters

Legal Advisory on Criminal Liability and Defense Strategy in Aggravated Injury and Assault Cases

Selected Matters

Lawyer
Shinyoung ChoiPartner
Case Summary

C&K Law Offices advised on the scope of criminal liability and defence strategy in a case of aggravated injury and assault. The matter shows that even in the same altercation, the legal assessment can vary greatly, from simple assault to aggravated injury, depending on the nature of any instrument, the form of participation and the degree of injury.

01Background

The case involved injuries arising from an altercation in which several people were involved. It was necessary to establish what charges could be made against the client and what should be contested in the investigation and at trial.

02Issues

There were three questions to examine in this case.

  1. 1

    Whether a dangerous object could be regarded as having been used.

  2. 2

    How far joint participation with others would be recognised.

  3. 3

    Whether there was causation between the conduct and the degree of the victim’s injury. The charges depended on the manner of the conduct, the nature of the instrument, the site of the injury and treatment period, and whether there had been prior conspiracy.

03Our Work

C&K Law Offices organised the facts against the elements of aggravated injury and assault under the Criminal Act. Aggravated injury is committed where injury is inflicted by displaying the force of a group or crowd or while carrying a dangerous object, so the nature of the instrument and how it was used were key to the charge.

We also reviewed the content and extent of intent and whether self-defence or a spontaneous act could be argued, and analysed how compensation of the victim and the progress of settlement would affect sentencing. On this basis, we reviewed step by step whether the charges were made out and set out the key issues and approach for the investigation and trial.

04Why This Case Matters

In assault cases, if the use of an instrument or conspiracy is admitted in early statements, the charges become more serious and are hard to change later. Whether an object is dangerous is, however, judged not only by its type but by how it was actually used, so there is room to contest it. It is therefore advisable to organise the facts before the first interview and also consider efforts to compensate the victim.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q. Is merely holding an object enough for aggravated injury?

If injury was inflicted while carrying a dangerous object, aggravated injury may be at issue. Whether the object is dangerous, however, is judged by looking at how it was used and the circumstances.

Q. Does settling with the victim end the case?

Injury and aggravated injury can be punished even if the victim does not want punishment. A settlement is, however, taken into account as a favourable factor in sentencing.

For enquiries, contact us at contact@chakwon.com.

All updates

Live ChatContact Us