Address
5F, 526 Nonhyeon-ro,
Gangnam-gu, Seoul, Korea
Address
5F, 526 Nonhyeon-ro,
Gangnam-gu, Seoul, Korea
C&K Law Offices advised an overseas company operating a blockchain-based platform and drafted a disclaimer concerning use of the service. The matter shows that when operating decentralised governance, users must be told clearly in advance how far votes are binding and what the operator is not responsible for.
The platform allowed users who had staked tokens to express views on the operation of the protocol by voting. Questions remained, such as whether the operator must follow voting results and who is responsible if a smart contract fails, and these needed to be addressed in the disclaimer.
Three questions were reviewed in this matter.
Whether governance votes are legally binding on the company.
How far liability arising from the execution of smart contracts can be limited.
How to address the risk of voting rights being regarded as securities.
C&K Law Offices first established that governance votes do not bind the company and set the scope of the company’s discretion in implementing them. We then structured the document to cover the limitation of liability for failure or delay in executing smart contracts and participants’ assumption of risk, the company’s right to intervene against vote manipulation and similar conduct, the public and irreversible nature of on-chain data, and the point that voting rights are not securities.
We set the items out separately because a disclaimer is effective only if participants can clearly see which risks they bear themselves.
C&K Law Offices organised the legal issues of participating in governance systematically and designed the disclaimer to clarify the operator’s scope of liability while giving participants sufficient notice.
Decentralised governance has the advantage of broadening user participation, but disputes easily arise when voting results and actual operation diverge. A disclaimer is not, however, a document that removes all liability, and its effect may be challenged if what it says differs from actual operation. It is therefore advisable to finalise the governance structure first and write the disclaimer to match it.
No. Some liabilities, such as those for wilful misconduct or gross negligence, are hard to limit even by disclaimer, and inadequate notice may render it ineffective.
Voting rights alone do not make it a security. Whether it is combined with a claim to the revenue of the business is the more important test.
More on our work is available on our Crypto Regulation & Advisory page. For enquiries, contact us at contact@chakwon.com.