Address
5F, 526 Nonhyeon-ro,
Gangnam-gu, Seoul, Korea
Address
5F, 526 Nonhyeon-ro,
Gangnam-gu, Seoul, Korea
C&K Law Offices advised a client planning to operate a virtual asset trading platform and reviewed whether the platform’s operating structure would make it a virtual asset service provider under the Act on Reporting and Using Specified Financial Transaction Information. The matter shows that even a platform promoted as enabling ‘direct trading between users’ may be regulated if the operator is involved in assets and the trading process.
The platform was presented as a structure in which users trade directly with one another. In actual operation, however, there was room to regard the operator as involved in users’ assets and the trading process. Although it was to be run by a foreign business, there were also elements suggesting that it would be doing business with Korean users.
Three questions were reviewed in this matter.
Whether the operator has effective control over users’ virtual assets.
Whether the operator is involved in trade execution and settlement.
Whether a foreign business would be regarded as doing business with Korean users.
C&K Law Offices reviewed the legal nature of the platform and the possible application of regulation against these three criteria. Whether a business is a virtual asset service provider depends not on how the service is presented but on what the operator actually does. The Act also applies to conduct abroad whose effects reach Korea, so being a foreign business is not in itself a way out of regulation.
We also proposed how the operating structure could be refined to reduce regulatory risk, and pointed out the need to revise the platform’s descriptions so that they match its actual functions.
Expressions such as ‘P2P’ and ‘non-custodial’ are often used as if they described structures that escape regulation. If the operator holds assets or is involved in settlement, however, it may be regarded as a virtual asset service provider regardless of the label, and a mismatch between description and actual function can itself be a problem. When designing a service, it is therefore advisable to settle the flow of asset custody and settlement first and then decide on the descriptions to match.
That cannot be assumed. If the operator matches orders or is involved in settlement or withdrawals, it may be regarded as brokering or as holding or managing assets.
If business in Korea is recognised, for example through a Korean-language service or marketing aimed at Korean users, Korean regulation may apply.
More on our work is available on our Crypto Regulation & Advisory page. For enquiries, contact us at contact@chakwon.com.