Address
5F, 526 Nonhyeon-ro,
Gangnam-gu, Seoul, Korea
Address
5F, 526 Nonhyeon-ro,
Gangnam-gu, Seoul, Korea
C&K Law Offices provided a legal review of whether Korean financial regulations could apply to a referral business structure that partners with an overseas financial service provider, directs users to an external trading platform and receives fees linked to users’ trading activity. The matter shows that once referral fees are linked to trading volume, the activity is far more likely to be assessed as investment solicitation or brokerage rather than simple advertising.
The client’s business introduced external trading services on an online platform and linked users’ sign-ups or trading to them. Its remuneration was linked to users’ trading activity, and it was necessary to establish whether this structure could be operated with Korean residents as the target market.
Two questions were reviewed in this matter.
Whether introducing, partnering and acquiring customers could be regarded as investment solicitation or brokerage where Korean residents are targeted.
Whether a reward structure linked to trading volume could be regarded as an economic interest that induces customers to trade.
C&K Law Offices examined, based on the actual way of operating and the reward structure, whether the referral activity was limited to simple advertising or provision of information, or whether it induced customers to trade particular financial products or involved the business in the trading process. Whether regulation applies is determined by what the business actually does, not by its name.
In particular, we analysed in light of the relevant legislation and regulators’ interpretations how rewards linked to trading volume differ from a structure in which Korean investors simply use a service of their own accord.
C&K Law Offices explained that if the current structure were operated as it stood for Korean residents, the application of Korean financial regulation could not be ruled out, and that there might be limits to maintaining the same structure even with a licence or registration. We therefore also proposed ways of adjusting the business structure, such as redesigning it as a general information and advertising model.
Referral models that introduce overseas financial services to Korean users in return for rewards look easy to enter but carry significant regulatory risk. Adjusting how rewards are paid and how services are introduced may, however, leave room to design the business as an advertising model. Before launching such a business, it is therefore advisable to check first how closely rewards are linked to trading volume and how far the business is involved in users’ trading decisions.
That cannot be assumed. If the fee is linked to users’ trading volume and actively encourages trading in particular products, the activity may be regarded as investment solicitation or brokerage.
If the activity is regarded as doing business with Korean residents, Korean regulation may apply. Factors such as a Korean-language service and marketing aimed at Korea are taken into account.
More on our work is available on our Crypto Regulation & Advisory page. For enquiries, contact us at contact@chakwon.com.