Address
5F, 526 Nonhyeon-ro,
Gangnam-gu, Seoul, Korea
Address
5F, 526 Nonhyeon-ro,
Gangnam-gu, Seoul, Korea
C&K Law Offices analysed the functions and token economy of a utility and governance token used in an overseas decentralised trading protocol and provided a legal opinion on whether the token constitutes a security under the Financial Investment Services and Capital Markets Act. The matter shows that even where a token has reward and burn mechanisms, its securities status should be assessed by whether holders acquire a claim to the revenue of the business.
The token under review was used in an automated market maker (AMM) trading protocol for ecosystem participation, liquidity provision incentives and governance voting. The protocol also used part of its fees to buy back and burn tokens.
The central question was whether the token’s functions and reward structure could be regarded as a right to receive returns from the performance of the business. In particular, buybacks and burns funded by fees tend to increase the token’s value, raising the question whether they should be treated as a distribution of profit.
Based on the elements of a financial investment product under the Capital Markets Act and the regulators’ criteria for investment contract securities, C&K Law Offices reviewed one by one the token’s staking and reward functions, liquidity provision incentives, governance rights and buyback-and-burn structure. The nature of the token as a whole can only be judged accurately by looking separately at what right each function gives holders.
C&K Law Offices gave the opinion that the token was unlikely to constitute a security under the Capital Markets Act, on the grounds that its functions were mainly for use of the protocol and participation in the ecosystem, that holding the token alone gave no contractual claim to the revenue of the business, and that the buyback and burn amounted to a supply management mechanism.
Tokens of decentralised protocols often combine usage, reward and governance functions. The same buyback-and-burn structure may be assessed differently, however, if it is designed or marketed as a way of distributing returns to holders. It is therefore advisable to check again, whenever the token economy is changed or marketing language is decided, that the change does not affect the securities analysis.
Burning alone does not immediately amount to a distribution of profit. The assessment looks at whether holders acquire a contractual right to claim returns and whether the purpose is supply management.
Voting rights alone do not make a token a security. The more important question is whether the voting rights are combined with a right to the revenue of the business.
More on our work is available on our Crypto Regulation & Advisory page. For enquiries, contact us at contact@chakwon.com.