Address
5F, 526 Nonhyeon-ro,
Gangnam-gu, Seoul, Korea
Address
5F, 526 Nonhyeon-ro,
Gangnam-gu, Seoul, Korea
C&K Law Offices advised a business planning to introduce a subscription payment service and provided a legal opinion on a sales structure based on long-term instalment payments and on the securitisation of the resulting receivables. The matter shows that a securitisation structure can only be designed properly by starting from the point that ownership of the goods and the receivables are separate legal relationships.
Under the client’s business, consumers paid the price of goods in instalments over a set period, and sales, payment and settlement passed through several entities. Because the client intended to raise funds using the resulting receivables, it was necessary to confirm that the sales structure and the securitisation fitted together legally.
Three questions were reviewed in this matter.
To whom, and when, ownership of the goods passes.
How the legal relationships are unwound if the consumer terminates early.
To which entity the receivables belong and whether they can be assigned or securitised.
C&K Law Offices reviewed the contractual structure focusing on the requirements for an instalment sale with retention of title and the legal ownership of the receivables. Proceeding on the basis that ownership of the goods and the receivables are separate legal relationships, we analysed where each right belongs. In a structure involving several entities, if it is unclear in which entity the receivables arise, the effectiveness of their assignment may be challenged at the securitisation stage.
We also considered how the possibility of assigning and securitising the receivables may vary with the contractual structure, and proposed adjustments to the structure suited to the business purpose.
C&K Law Offices set out the main considerations and practical points for designing the contracts and transaction structure so that the subscription sales structure and the securitisation of receivables are legally consistent.
Because revenue from subscription sales comes in over a long period, there is strong demand to securitise receivables in advance to fund operations. If the sales contract and settlement structure are not designed with securitisation in mind from the start, however, ownership or assignability of the receivables may later be called into question. It is therefore advisable to settle the sales contract, settlement flow and ownership of receivables together at the service design stage.
Not necessarily. Ownership and receivables are separate rights, so who is the creditor for the price under the contract must be checked separately.
The amount of the receivable may be reduced or extinguished on termination. That is why the securitisation agreement should also set out settlement on termination and the method of substituting receivables.
More on our work is available on our Commercial Transactions page. For enquiries, contact us at contact@chakwon.com.