HOME / Updates / Selected Matters

Ownership and Continuing Transaction Rules for Subscription-Based Consumer Goods

Selected Matters

Practice areaCorporate & Commercial
Case Summary

C&K Law Offices advised a business planning to sell subscription-based consumer goods linked to an app-based service on long-term instalment terms, reviewing the structure of ownership of the goods and whether the rules on continuing transactions applied. The matter shows that in subscription sales, when ownership passes also changes the legal relationships on termination and settlement.

01Overview

Under the client’s business, users would use consumer goods while paying for them in instalments over a long period and continue to receive a linked service. Because the sale of goods and provision of services were combined, the applicable regulation could differ depending on how the contract was characterised.

02Issues

Three questions were reviewed in this matter.

  1. 1

    When ownership of the goods passes to the user.

  2. 2

    How the goods are returned and the price settled if the user terminates early.

  3. 3

    Whether the consumer protection rules on continuing transactions apply to the structure.

03Our Work

C&K Law Offices focused its review on the time of delivery of the goods, the time of full payment and the contractual structure for transfer of ownership. We then analysed what must be included in the contract and terms if it were designed as an instalment sale with retention of title, under which the seller retains ownership until the price is paid in full. Retaining ownership with the seller provides a clear basis for demanding return of the goods on early termination.

Since the service would be provided continuously over a long period, however, the arrangement could also be a continuing transaction. On that assumption, we also reviewed matters to consider relating to termination, settlement and user protection.

04Why This Case Matters

Subscription sales reduce users’ upfront burden and are spreading across many sectors. A structure combining sales and services may, however, have the character of both an instalment transaction and a continuing transaction, so terms drafted with only one regime in mind may leave the termination and settlement clauses open to challenge. Before launch, it is therefore advisable to decide first when ownership passes and how settlement works on termination, and to design the terms accordingly.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q. What is an instalment sale with retention of title?

A method under which the goods are handed over first but the seller retains ownership until the price is paid in full. It provides the basis for the seller to demand return of the goods if payments fall into arrears or the contract is terminated.

Q. What changes if it is a continuing transaction?

Protective rules on consumers’ right to terminate and on penalties on termination may apply. Whether the termination and settlement clauses in the terms comply with these rules should be checked.

More on our work is available on our Commercial Transactions page. For enquiries, contact us at contact@chakwon.com.

All updates

Live ChatContact Us