HOME / Updates / Selected Matters

Sales Organization Commission Structure under Multi-Level Marketing and Sponsored Door-to-Door Sales

Selected Matters

Practice areaCorporate & Commercial
Case Summary

C&K Law Offices advised a business operating a sales organisation and reviewed whether its commission structure for sales representatives amounted to multi-level marketing or sponsored door-to-door sales under the Door-to-Door Sales Act. The matter shows that it is not the name of a sales organisation but the actual recruitment relationships and method of paying allowances that determine whether regulation applies.

01Overview

Under the client’s business, sellers received commission according to their own sales, and some participants received consideration for separate tasks they performed. As a sales organisation grows, however, hierarchical relationships easily develop among sales representatives and the allowance structure tends to become complex, so it was necessary to review whether the structure could be regarded as a sales organisation requiring separate registration.

02Issues

The Door-to-Door Sales Act defines multi-level marketing as sales through a sales organisation in which (1) representatives recruit particular persons to join as their downline, (2) such recruitment proceeds in three or more tiers (including cases prescribed by Presidential Decree where an organisation of two tiers or fewer is in practice managed as three or more), and (3) the business pays sponsorship allowances based on other representatives’ sales or organisational management and training performance (Article 2(5)). Sponsored door-to-door sales meets the requirements of door-to-door sales and multi-level marketing but uses a payment method under which a representative’s performance affects only the sponsorship allowance of the single immediate upline representative (Article 2(7)).

The issues in this matter were therefore

  1. 1

    whether there was a real upline-downline recruitment relationship between representatives,

  2. 2

    whether representatives received allowances linked to other representatives’ performance rather than their own, and

  3. 3

    whether the consideration for separate tasks in effect functioned as an additional tier of the sales organisation.

03Our Work

C&K Law Offices reviewed the substance of the organisation by examining separately the recruitment relationships, the organisational tiers and the method of paying allowances. The test is not the wording in contracts or business descriptions but who actually recruits whom and how allowances flow.

We concluded that the structure as it stood was not likely to amount to multi-level marketing or sponsored door-to-door sales. We also explained that the position could change if the recruitment relationships or allowance system changed in future.

04Why This Case Matters

As a business grows, sales organisations often come to be operated differently from their original design. Falling within multi-level marketing or sponsored door-to-door sales brings separate obligations such as registration, however, so whether regulation applies must be re-checked each time the allowance system changes. It is therefore safer not to stop at an initial review but to continue checking as the organisation’s operation changes.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q. If a representative introduces an acquaintance, is it automatically multi-level marketing?

No. The assessment looks together at whether the introduction leads to downline recruitment, how many tiers the organisation operates in and whether allowances linked to other representatives’ performance are paid.

Q. Should the structure be reviewed again if the allowance system changes?

Yes. If allowances become linked to other representatives’ performance, whether regulation applies may change.

More on our work is available on our Commercial Transactions page. For enquiries, contact us at contact@chakwon.com.

All updates

Live ChatContact Us