HOME / Updates / Selected Matters

Success on Sanction Level Alleviation from FSC Sanctions (2)

Selected Matters

Case Summary

C&K Law Offices represented a financial institution in sanction proceedings before the Financial Supervisory Service’s Sanctions Review Committee and the Financial Services Commission (May–July 2021), reducing a planned business suspension to a cautionary warning. The matter shows that the level of a sanction can be reduced substantially by relying on the supervisory authority’s past stance and industry practice.

01Background

The client, a financial institution, faced a planned sanction following an inspection by the Financial Supervisory Service, and the sanction planned was a business suspension.

02Issues

The central question was whether it was appropriate to hold the financial institution heavily responsible for the business practice in question.

03Our Work

C&K Law Offices actively argued four points. First, the law on the issues in question was ambiguous. Second, the signals sent to the market by various administrative authorities were unclear, so confusion on the part of financial institutions was inevitable. Third, the Financial Supervisory Service had identified the same issue in earlier industry inspections without ever imposing sanctions or requiring correction. Fourth, there was no example in other inspections of correction being required for the same business practice.

As a result, at the Sanctions Review Committee hearing, the Financial Supervisory Service’s inspection team acknowledged that its approach to the issue had changed from July 2020. The argument that it was unfair to apply the same standard to conduct before the supervisory authority’s stance changed gained force.

04Outcome

The planned level of sanction was lowered by two levels at the Financial Supervisory Service’s Sanctions Review Committee and by a further level in the Financial Services Commission’s decision, reducing the planned business suspension to a cautionary warning.

05Why This Case Matters

When a financial institution responds to sanction proceedings on its own, it often fails to set out its arguments in documentary form even when they are sound, or its business suffers from the workload. Relying on the supervisory authority’s past inspection history and industry circumstances, however, leaves considerable room to contest the level of sanction. When a sanction is planned, it is therefore advisable to start by compiling the supervisory history and industry examples.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q. Can the level of sanction be contested before the Sanctions Review Committee?

There is an opportunity to submit opinions and make statements, so explaining the circumstances may lower the level of sanction.

Q. What happens to earlier conduct if the supervisory authority’s standard changed?

It can be argued that applying the changed standard to conduct before the change is unfair.

More on our work is available on our Commercial Transactions page. For enquiries, contact us at contact@chakwon.com.

All updates

Live ChatContact Us