Address
5F, 526 Nonhyeon-ro,
Gangnam-gu, Seoul, Korea
Address
5F, 526 Nonhyeon-ro,
Gangnam-gu, Seoul, Korea
C&K Law Offices represented a Korean financial institution in a partial inspection by the Financial Supervisory Service (November 2020 to March 2021), reducing the violation amount initially notified by the FSS to around 20 per cent. The matter shows that where the FSS’s inspection practice departs from Supreme Court case law, the calculation of violation amounts can be contested on that basis.
Following advance notice, the client underwent a partial inspection by the Financial Supervisory Service. Requests for materials continued beyond the formal inspection period, so the inspection in effect lasted five months.
The central issue was how the violation amount was calculated. The FSS had inflated the violation amount by splitting into several legal relationships activities that, under Supreme Court case law, could be regarded as a single product, and in line with its previous inspection practice had also split facts that should have been treated as a single legal relationship.
C&K Law Offices prepared more than ten written opinions and supporting materials arguing that the FSS’s working practice differed from the Supreme Court’s position. We also pointed out that the formula for calculating the violation amount was built on inconsistent criteria, making the amount excessive. The key was to show clearly that Supreme Court case law takes precedence over the FSS’s practice.
The FSS revised its inspection opinion, and the violation amount was reduced to around 20 per cent of the amount initially notified.
FSS inspections are often conducted according to long-standing practice, which financial institutions tend to accept as it is. Where that practice departs from case law, however, the difference can be used to reduce violation amounts and the level of sanctions significantly. On receiving an inspection opinion, it is therefore advisable first to check whether the calculation criteria are consistent with case law.
Yes. Problems with the calculation criteria can be raised in written opinions during the inspection and in the subsequent sanction proceedings.
Anticipate the issues from the materials requested, industry issues and the internal situation, and plan responses in advance.
More on our work is available on our Commercial Transactions page. For enquiries, contact us at contact@chakwon.com.