HOME / Updates / Selected Matters

eDiscovery Privilege Review and Log Drafting for U.S. Litigation

Selected Matters

Practice areaDispute Resolution
Case Summary

C&K Law Offices reviewed evidentiary documents for privilege (attorney-client privilege) in the eDiscovery phase of U.S. litigation to which a Korean company was a party, and prepared privilege logs. In U.S. litigation, accurately identifying the documents that need not be handed over to the other side is itself a way of protecting the company’s right of defence.

01Overview

Before trial in U.S. litigation, the parties go through discovery, in which they disclose documents relevant to the case to each other. Not every document has to be disclosed, however. Confidential communications between a lawyer and a client for the purpose of legal advice are protected by privilege, and their disclosure can be refused.

The client in this matter, a Korean company, likewise had to identify which of a large volume of internal documents were protected by privilege.

02Issues

A privilege review raised two questions.

  1. 1

    Whether each document met the requirements for privilege protection. Even a conversation involving a lawyer may not be protected if it is a business discussion rather than legal advice.

  2. 2

    Whether the documents withheld were recorded accurately in the privilege log so that the other side and the court could check them. An inaccurate log can lead to disputes over the documents for which protection is claimed.

03Our Work

C&K Law Offices reviewed each evidentiary document for privilege and prepared logs for the documents confirmed as privileged. Because this work requires an understanding of U.S. litigation procedure, foreign-qualified attorneys with U.S. litigation experience took part as reviewers.

Our review manager and foreign-qualified attorney reviewers also worked in close consultation with the U.S. law firms conducting the litigation. Aligning the review standards with U.S. counsel prevents conflicting judgements at later stages of the proceedings.

04Why This Case Matters

When a Korean company becomes involved in U.S. litigation, the volume of documents to be handled at the discovery stage is considerable. Many of those documents are written in Korean, so without reviewers who understand both the Korean language and U.S. litigation procedure, errors in privilege decisions are easy to make. A Korean law firm handling document review in cooperation with U.S. law firms therefore adds value in both accuracy and efficiency.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q. Are emails exchanged with in-house counsel also protected by privilege?

They can be, if the communication was made to seek or provide legal advice. If it mainly concerns business decisions, however, the scope of protection may differ, so each document must be reviewed individually.

Q. What goes into a privilege log?

Typically the date of the document, its author and recipients, the type of document and the basis for claiming protection. The exact format depends on the case and the court’s requirements.

More on our cross-border work is available on our Recovery and Enforcement page. For enquiries, contact us at contact@chakwon.com.

All updates

Live ChatContact Us