Address
5F, 526 Nonhyeon-ro,
Gangnam-gu, Seoul, Korea
Address
5F, 526 Nonhyeon-ro,
Gangnam-gu, Seoul, Korea
C&K Law Offices provided a legal review to an overseas business planning to operate a peer-to-peer (P2P) virtual asset trading platform on whether the platform would be subject to reporting as a virtual asset service provider under the Act on Reporting and Using Specified Financial Transaction Information. The conclusion was that the assessment depends not on the label ‘non-custodial’ but on how far the operator is actually involved in users’ assets and trades.
The client designed the platform on the premise of a non-custodial P2P trading structure in which users control their own assets. The basic concept was that users trade directly with one another and the operator does not hold assets.
On closer examination of the design, however, it had not yet been decided who would manage the trading wallets and private keys, or how far the operator would be involved in matching, settlement and withdrawals. Whether to accept Korean users also needed to be reviewed.
The Act imposes a reporting obligation to the Commissioner of the Korea Financial Intelligence Unit on anyone who, as a business, buys, sells, exchanges, transfers, holds or manages virtual assets, or brokers, arranges or acts as agent for their sale or exchange (Article 7(1)). The questions in this matter were therefore
whether the operator could be regarded as holding or managing users’ virtual assets, and
whether the operator could be regarded as brokering, arranging or acting as agent for sales or exchanges.
C&K Law Offices based its review on how the platform would actually operate rather than on its name or form. Even under the same ‘P2P’ label, a structure that allows the operator to touch users’ assets may be regarded as no different from a custodial exchange.
We therefore analysed the asset control structure first, examining whether there was holding or management with a focus on who keeps the private keys of the trading wallets and whether the operator can move users’ assets. Next, we separated out the operator’s role at each stage of order matching, execution, settlement and withdrawal to assess whether it amounted to brokerage, arrangement or agency.
We also reviewed whether the business would be regarded as operating in Korea. We looked at whether a Korean-language service would be offered and whether business and marketing would target Korean users, to assess whether the Act could apply extraterritorially. Finally, based on this analysis, we set out how the operating structure and the management of users’ assets could be adjusted to reduce regulatory risk.
C&K Law Offices gave the opinion that, depending on the extent of the operator’s asset management and involvement in trades, the platform could be regarded not as non-custodial but as structurally similar to a custodial exchange, and that the reporting obligation under the Act could become an issue if the business were regarded as targeting Korean users. We also proposed practical improvements to reduce the risk.
Trading services promoting themselves as ‘P2P’, ‘non-custodial’ or ‘decentralised’ have been increasing. Whether regulation applies is not decided by such labels, however. Who keeps the private keys and whether the operator has withdrawal or settlement authority weigh more heavily in the assessment.
Nor is an overseas entity free from Korean regulation simply because it is overseas. Offering a Korean-language service or marketing to Koreans may be regarded as doing business in Korea. Having the structure reviewed at the design stage rather than after launch therefore reduces the burden of changing it later.
That cannot be assumed. If the operator matches orders or is involved in settlement or withdrawals, it may be regarded as brokering, arranging or acting as agent, or as holding or managing assets.
If there is no Korean-language service or marketing aimed at Koreans and Korean users are actually blocked, the likelihood of extraterritorial application may be lower. The blocking method and actual operation must be checked together, however.
At the service design stage, before the wallet structure and settlement method are fixed. After launch, contractual relationships with users already exist, making it much harder to change the structure.
More on our work is available on our Crypto Regulation & Advisory page. For enquiries, contact us at contact@chakwon.com.